When it comes to investing, picking individual stocks may seem tempting, but unless you have exceptional skills or years of experience, it’s akin to gambling with your hard-earned money. This blog post aims to shed light on the drawbacks of stock picking as an investment strategy and suggests alternatives that Canadian investors should consider. So, let’s dive in and explore why relying solely on stock picking may not be the best choice for your investment portfolio.

Unpredictability of the Market

Investing in stocks requires extensive research, but even then, the market remains highly unpredictable. Determining the right time to buy or sell is a daunting task, as market dynamics can quickly change. It’s like trying to predict the weather accurately. The truth is, even with substantial efforts, no one can consistently time the market and make profitable trades.

Long-Term Risks of Holding Individual Stocks

The notion of holding individual stocks for the long term may seem attractive, but history has shown that even seemingly stable companies can face unexpected challenges. Factors like ill-advised tweets from CEOs, marketing mishaps, or being outpaced by a rapidly evolving global economy can lead to substantial drops in stock valuations. This reality makes relying solely on individual stocks a risky and unreliable option for long-term investments.

Lack of Competitive Edge

Finding an edge in stock picking has become exceedingly difficult. Stock prices already reflect what the market feels the stock will be worth in the future (not the present) based on all publicly available information, making it challenging for individual investors to discover hidden gems. Even if you believe you’ve found an exceptional opportunity through thorough research, it’s highly likely that others have reached the same conclusion. Investment firms possess vast resources and information, making it nearly impossible for individual investors to compete.

Poor Diversification

Investing in individual stocks often leads to a poorly diversified portfolio. Unless you own a vast number of securities that accurately mirror the global markets, your investments can be highly concentrated and vulnerable to market fluctuations. This lack of diversification exposes you to unnecessary risks, which can have a significant impact on your overall investment performance.

Illusion of Big Wins

We often hear stories of individuals who score big wins in the stock market, but these successes are typically short-lived. Beating the market consistently year after year is virtually impossible. Furthermore, the stories of significant losses accompanying these wins are often overshadowed. Over the long term, losses tend to outweigh the gains, making it challenging to sustain profitable stock picking strategies.

Costs of Hiring Advisors

You might consider hiring an advisor to choose stocks on your behalf, but the math shows that the odds of beating the market are about 50/50. Moreover, the fees charged by advisors and mutual funds are substantially higher than those of low-cost index funds. Even seemingly small fees, like a 2% annual fee, can significantly impact your long-term returns, potentially costing you hundreds of thousands of dollars in the future, or even millions.  An advisor would not just need to beat the market consistently, but they would need to beat the market by more than their 2% fee and history has shown and the vast majority of investment professionals cannot accomplish this.

As an example, for a $100,000 investment, 2% will take $200 off the top.  Ok that’s not so bad, but what will the investment look like in 25 years?  After the 2% fee the $100,000 would turn into $338,636 (based on a 7% yearly return).  Without that fee you would be looking at $542,743.  That’s a difference of over $200,000; 37.6% of the portfolio.  So, 2% is not really 2%.  History has shown that advisors simply cannot beat the market consistently over the long term, and certainly not by enough to make up for the difference their fees will cost.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Canadian investors should think twice before relying solely on stock picking as their investment strategy. The market’s unpredictability, lack of competitive edge, risks of holding individual stocks, poor diversification, and hidden costs of hiring advisors all point to the need for alternative approaches. Consider exploring low-cost index funds and developing a diversified portfolio tailored to your risk tolerance and investment horizon. By doing so, you can enhance your chances of long-term investment success while minimizing unnecessary risks and expenses.

Check out our article entitled ‘No More Fees Please’ by clicking below, and see how you can enjoy massive savings off of the fees charged by robo-advisors by taking the Tater course.